Singing and making music: why it matters to us
Last updated · by PhonicScore
In short
Singing helps shape who we become. It is remarkable how many positive effects are linked to it.
Singing helps shape who we become. It is remarkable how many positive effects are linked to it.
When the virus broke out, classrooms went quiet. No more music lessons. Children could no longer sing. The pandemic left its mark here too, and with it on the lives of young people. With what effect? It makes a difference whether or not children learn to sing when they are young. Research shows that singing and making music together builds not only musicality but other skills as well, and these have a positive effect on how children’s personalities develop.
Singing with children: does music help at school?
In a baby’s first year, singing and speaking are not yet separate. Through “musilanguage”, babies express hunger, thirst, joy, pain or contentment. Later they show their musical side: they sway, bob along to rhythms, and sounds move them. Melody, articulation, sentence structure, tempo and stress: singing songs then calls for an understanding of all of these, and for concentration. Songs also teach content in a playful way.
Scientists say that developing musicality builds cognitive skills: recognizing patterns and sequences, noticing differences, counting, and symbolic thinking. Emotional skills (feeling and expressing emotions) and motor skills are involved as well.
Researchers at the Canto research institute in Germany went further after an empirical study of 500 kindergarten children: they argue that developing children’s ability to sing should even have consequences for education policy. According to the study, singing supports children’s physical, mental and social development. Preschoolers who sing a lot were significantly more often ready for school than preschoolers who sing little, so singing gives them a head start in education.
Singing together connects us: many positive effects
The scientific evidence for some of these links is thin, though. The belief, for example, that any kind of music-making goes along with better social skills or makes people easier to get along with cannot be backed up. What is clearly established, the Bertelsmann Stiftung concludes, is the positive link between musical activity and language acquisition. More recent empirical research also shows pro-social effects of making music together, based on the experience of being in sync. There are also signs that making music over a long time in childhood and adolescence (ten years or more) can have a positive effect on cognitive performance.
So there are positive transfer effects. And by the way, the documented psychological effects of singing include a better mood and general well-being, relaxation and less stress, mental activation, spiritual experience, a better self-image and greater self-efficacy, and feelings of social connection. Many people say music helped them get through the pandemic more calmly.
Emotional development: expressing feelings through music
Singing also lets people, and especially children and teenagers, express their emotions in creative and expressive ways. Melodies, lyrics and the chance to sing in different registers and styles give feelings room to unfold. This can help build emotional intelligence, as young people learn to recognize their own emotions, name them and handle them well.
Does singing strengthen the immune system?
Scientists have looked into this question as well, and the first results are interesting but small. In one study, members of an amateur choir had more of an antibody in their saliva (secretory immunoglobulin A) after an hour of singing, and felt better, while listening to the same music did not have that effect (Kreutz and colleagues, 2004). In another, an hour of choir singing went along with better mood, lower stress hormones and changes in several immune proteins in people affected by cancer (Fancourt and colleagues, 2016).
These studies measured short-term changes in small groups. They do not show that singing protects anyone from illness, and the effect will differ from person to person. To sum up, you could say: music does many people good, and singing is a pleasant way to relax.
Sources
- Singen in der Kindheit. Eine empirische Studie zur Gesundheit und Schulfähigkeit von Kindergartenkindern und das Canto elementar-Konzept zum Praxistransfer. Waxmann (Karl Adamek, Thomas Blank; Canto research institute), record in the Fachportal Pädagogik, 2010
- Gembris, expert report (MIKA project). Bertelsmann Stiftung
- Effects of choir singing or listening on secretory immunoglobulin A, cortisol, and emotional state. Journal of Behavioral Medicine (Kreutz, Bongard, Rohrmann, Hodapp, Grebe), 2004
- Singing modulates mood, stress, cortisol, cytokine and neuropeptide activity in cancer patients and carers. ecancermedicalscience (Fancourt, Williamon, Carvalho, Steptoe, Dow, Lewis), 2016