Skip to content

Am I tone deaf? Almost certainly not

Last updated

In short

Probably not. True tone deafness, called congenital amusia, affected about 1.5 percent of people in a study of 20,000 participants. Far more people believe they are tone deaf than are. If you notice when someone else sings a wrong note, your ear works. What usually needs practice is the step from hearing a note to singing it.

In short

  • Congenital amusia is real but rare: about 1 person in 70.
  • In one survey, nearly 17 percent of students called themselves tone deaf. Testing found that many of them had no perceptual difficulty.
  • Singing off key and hearing badly are two different things. Most off-key singers hear pitch normally.
  • A two-minute check below tells you which group you are probably in.

How rare is real tone deafness?

Rarer than its reputation. Isabelle Peretz and Dominique Vuvan at the University of Montreal tested 20,000 participants with three objective tests and a questionnaire. They put the prevalence of congenital amusia at about 1.5 percent, slightly more often in women than in men (Peretz and Vuvan, 2017). The 4 percent you may have read elsewhere came, as they point out, from a single test in 1980.

Compare that with how many people think they have it. When Lola Cuddy and colleagues surveyed more than 2,000 first-year psychology students in Canada, nearly 17 percent reported being tone deaf. They then tested 100 of those students with a standard amusia battery, and concluded that many people who consider themselves tone deaf do not have perceptual difficulties (Cuddy and colleagues, 2005).

The gap is even wider for singing. In a prescreening questionnaire of 1,105 students, 59 percent said they could not imitate melodies by singing. When Peter Pfordresher and Steven Brown actually tested singers, 10 to 15 percent sang a semitone or more off, and those poor-pitch singers heard pitch differences as well as the good singers (Pfordresher and Brown, 2007).

So most people who say “I’m tone deaf” mean “I don’t trust my singing”. That is a different problem, and a solvable one.

How can I check in two minutes?

This is not a diagnosis. It tells you whether your ear is likely to be the problem.

  1. The wrong-note test. Think of a time someone sang badly at a birthday party or in karaoke. Did it sound wrong to you? Or ask a friend to sing or play “Happy Birthday” with one clearly wrong note, and listen for it.
  2. The tune test. Hum the first line of “Happy Birthday” or “Jingle Bells” in your head, without words. Can you hear the melody? Could you recognize either song if someone hummed it?
  3. Higher or lower. On a free piano app, play two neighboring keys, one after the other, in random order. Can you say which one was higher, most of the time?
  4. One note, out loud. Play a comfortable note and hum it. Record both and play them back. Do they sound the same, or can you hear that they differ?

How to read it. If you heard the wrong note and recognized the tunes, your pitch perception is very likely fine, even if step 4 went badly. That combination is the most common one, and it is what practice fixes. If you could not hear wrong notes at all, could not recognize familiar tunes without words, and could not tell higher from lower even with keys far apart, talk to a music teacher or an audiologist, and read the next section.

What is congenital amusia?

Congenital amusia is a lifelong difficulty with musical pitch that is not explained by hearing loss or brain injury. In a detailed study of 11 adults, Julie Ayotte, Isabelle Peretz and Krista Hyde found severe problems in processing pitch variations, which extended to remembering and recognizing music, singing and tapping in time. Speech, voices and everyday sounds were processed normally (Ayotte and colleagues, 2002).

A later study measured brain responses and found that the amusic brain does register small pitch changes, but people with amusia are not aware of them and do not react to notes that break the key of a melody (Peretz and colleagues, 2009). That is why the wrong-note test above is a good first check: hearing that a note does not belong is exactly what amusia takes away.

Two facts from the 2017 prevalence study are worth knowing. Amusia runs in families: 46 percent of first-degree relatives were also affected. And musical training did not reduce the deficit. If you have it, singing in tune may stay out of reach.

Why was I told I can’t sing?

Many adults who are sure they cannot sing remember the exact moment they were told so: a choir audition at eight, a teacher who asked them to mouth the words, a sibling who laughed. Steven Demorest and Peter Pfordresher note that the label “tone deaf” can do lasting damage to a child’s view of their own musicality, and that those childhood experiences are remembered vividly into adulthood (Demorest and Pfordresher, 2015).

Their study also found something surprising. Singing accuracy improved a lot from kindergarten to late elementary school, but overall the college students they tested sang no more accurately than the kindergartners. The authors suggest that singing skill may decline when it is not used. So an adult who stopped singing at ten may sound worse today than at ten, for reasons that have nothing to do with talent.

Two more things make people sound worse than they are:

  • Songs in the wrong key. A song pitched for someone else’s voice pulls you off. Low voices trying to sing a song pitched for high voices tend to go flat on the top notes.
  • Speed. In a Montreal study, most occasional singers sang a familiar song as accurately as professionals once they slowed down (Dalla Bella and colleagues, 2007).

What should I do next?

If your ear passed the check, treat singing like any other skill you never practiced.

  1. Find a note that is easy for your voice: say “mm-hmm” and hold the “mm”.
  2. Match that note from a piano app or from a recording of yourself.
  3. Move to two and three notes in small steps, slowly.
  4. Check yourself with a recording or a tuner app, not with your feelings.

The full set of exercises is in How to sing in tune.

When is someone else the better answer?

  • A singing teacher or choir director if you practice for a few weeks and your notes still do not land. A trained listener can hear whether the problem is the key, the tempo, tension or the ear.
  • An audiologist if you have trouble hearing in general, not only with music.
  • A doctor, usually an ear, nose and throat specialist, if singing hurts or your voice stays hoarse.

If you think you might have amusia, research groups that study it, such as the BRAMS laboratory in Montreal where much of the work above was done, use standard test batteries. A self-check on a website cannot replace them.

Questions and answers

What percentage of people are tone deaf?

About 1.5 percent, according to the largest prevalence study so far, which tested 20,000 participants. An older and often quoted figure of 4 percent came from a single test from 1980.

Can tone deaf people learn to sing?

Most people who call themselves tone deaf are not, and they can learn to sing in tune with practice. For people with congenital amusia, the 2017 study found that musical training did not reduce the deficit.

Is singing off key the same as being tone deaf?

No. Many people who sing off key hear pitch normally. In lab studies, inaccurate singers told pitches apart as well as accurate singers; their difficulty was in producing the note.

Can a child be tone deaf?

Congenital amusia is lifelong, so it exists in children too, but it is rare. A child who sings off key usually needs songs in a better key and more chances to sing, not a label.

Sources

  1. Prevalence of congenital amusia. European Journal of Human Genetics (Peretz, Vuvan), 2017
  2. Musical difficulties are rare: a study of 'tone deafness' among university students. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences (Cuddy, Balkwill, Peretz, Holden), 2005
  3. Poor-pitch singing in the absence of tone deafness. Music Perception (Pfordresher, Brown), 2007
  4. Congenital amusia: a group study of adults afflicted with a music-specific disorder. Brain (Ayotte, Peretz, Hyde), 2002
  5. The amusic brain: in tune, out of key, and unaware. Brain (Peretz, Brattico, Järvenpää, Tervaniemi), 2009
  6. Singing accuracy development from K-adult: a comparative study. Music Perception (Demorest, Pfordresher), 2015
  7. Singing proficiency in the general population. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America (Dalla Bella, Giguère, Peretz), 2007